Fundamental Problems with Visual Performance Research Described in the CIE 19/2 Report

Publication Type

Conference Paper

LBNL Report Number

LBL-16220

Abstract

The CIE 1912 model of performance cannot be used to predict performance or productivity. We present counter-examples to the link assumed in CIE 19/2 between performance and productivity. Statistical arguments show that the fitting parameters are not physically determined as was thought and that the curve fitting in the CIE 1912 report does not constitute a validation.

Some critics of CIE 1912 have suggested that RQQ #6 be used in its place for lighting calculations. RQQ #6 is simply a consensus of present practice. The more robust visibility trends presented in CIE 19/2 are inconsistent with the recommendations in RQQ #6. Careful use of the material in CIE 19/2 could lead to better recommendations than are exemplified by RQQ #6.

Conference Name

1983 IES Annual Conference

Year of Publication

1983

Conference Location

Los Angeles, CA

Call Number

LBL-16220